Babylon Fish & Clam, Family-Run Since 1970, Sold in September 2026 for $275,000. The New Owners Are Aiming to Reopen Around Christmas

November 5, 2026·SYR Editorial·3 min read

RESTAURANT SALES | NEW YORK

The family behind the Babylon Village clam bar, dining room and fish market served its last meals on Labor Day and handed over the keys two days later.

By SYR News | Oct. 29, 2026

AI-generated photo

Babylon Fish & Clam at 458 Fire Island Ave. in Babylon Village, N.Y., has changed hands. The family that has run it since 1970 announced the sale on the restaurant's Facebook page, and said the buyers plan to reopen around Christmas, Long Island Wave reported Oct. 23.

The family's last day of service was Labor Day, Sept. 7. The restaurant closed the next day, and the keys went to the new owners that Wednesday, Sept. 9. The Agency Long Island, the brokerage that listed the business, records the sale as closing Sept. 9 at $275,000.

What the buyer gets

  • A clam bar and a dining room serving seafood, steak and pasta, with indoor and outdoor seating
  • A fresh fish market in the same building, which the listing described as an added source of income
  • Private parking, which the listing called a rarity in the village
  • Price: $275,000, per the brokerage's record of the sale
  • Real estate: the listing said the seller also owns the property and offered a long-term lease to the buyer
  • Still to come: the new owners have not announced a name, menu or opening date

“When a longtime owner moves that fast, the buyer has to be ready at the closing table, not after it”

A seafood house with a second register

A retail fish counter lets a seafood restaurant earn from the same deliveries twice: once on the plate and once over the counter. For a buyer, that can steady sales in slower dining months. It also means two sets of rules to follow, since a retail food counter and a restaurant can need separate permits and inspections.

Keys in two days

The family handed over the keys within two days of its last service. When a longtime owner moves that fast, the buyer has to be ready at the closing table, not after it.

  • Have the lease signed before closing, with its length, rent and renewal options in writing
  • Apply early for the permits the new operation needs, including any for the retail fish market
  • If you plan to serve alcohol, start the State Liquor Authority process well ahead, because a new owner needs a license in its own name
  • Ask for recipes, supplier contacts and the restaurant's phone number, website and social media accounts as part of the deal
  • Agree on whether the Babylon Fish & Clam name comes with the sale

Key Takeaways

  • Babylon Fish & Clam in Babylon Village, N.Y., family-run since 1970, has been sold, and the new owners hope to reopen around Christmas.
  • The listing brokerage records the sale as closing Sept. 9, 2026, at $275,000.
  • The listing offered a long-term lease from the seller, who also owns the property.
  • With keys handed over two days after the last service, the buyer's lease, permits and licensing had to be ready at closing.

Sources

Long Island Wave, "Babylon Fish & Clam Has Been Sold, and the New Owners Aim to Reopen Around Christmas" (Oct. 23, 2026): https://longislandwave.com/news/babylon-fish-and-clam-sold-reopening-christmas-2026/

The Agency Long Island, sold listing for 458 Fire Island Ave., Babylon, N.Y. (MLS 934833): https://theagencyre3.com/properties/458-fire-island-avenue-babylon-ny-11702-key934833