Alabama Jack's, on Key Largo's Card Sound Road Since 1947, Is Listed at $4.9 Million. The Buyer Gets a Federal Lease Through 2041, Not the Land
FEDERAL LAND LEASE | FLORIDA
The October 2026 relisting covers the business, the brand and the conch fritter recipe on a site leased from the U.S. government, so the lease is what a buyer is really underwriting.
By SYR News | Oct. 23, 2026
Alabama Jack's, the open-air waterfront bar and restaurant at 58000 Card Sound Road in Key Largo, Fla., is back on the market at $4.9 million, the Miami Herald reported on Oct. 16. Listing agent Curtis Skomp of RE/MAX All Keys Real Estate told the Herald that the property had been listed before and pulled from the market, and that the relisting had already drawn "several serious bites" from parties who indicated they would keep the place running.
The price buys the business. It does not buy the ground. The site is leased from the federal government, and the lease was last renewed in 2021 for 20 years, according to the Herald. Skomp told the paper that renewals have always been approved. The listing says the current term runs through 2041.
What the $4.9 million covers
- The restaurant business and the Alabama Jack's name and brand
- Equipment and the merchandise operation; the listing also mentions a retail T-shirt business
- The recipes, including the house conch fritters
- Per the listing, the business's domain names and Facebook page, plus all furniture, fixtures and equipment
- Not included: the land, which stays with the federal government
“When the ground isn't part of the sale, the price pays for the right to keep operating on it”
The property
- Two parcels at 58000 Card Sound Road totaling 41,602 square feet, a little under an acre
- 7,026 square feet of restaurant and covered outdoor space; the listing splits that into 2,297 square feet of finished space and 4,729 square feet under canopy
- More than 360 linear feet of docks, direct water access and a small apartment above the restaurant
- A desalination system and a backup water truck with a tank, per the listing
A Keys landmark with one owner family since 1980
Alabama Jack's began as a fishing hangout started by Jack Stratham, who placed an abandoned railroad building on pilings partly over the water, the Herald reported. Hurricane Betsy knocked the building off its pilings in 1965; it was rebuilt on a barge and reopened in March 1966. Phyllis Sague and her son, Mike, have owned and run it since 1980, according to the Herald, and it remains open.
The lease is the deal
When the ground isn't part of the sale, the price pays for the right to keep operating on it, along with the earnings that right produces. With the current term running through 2041, a buyer closing in 2026 would have about 15 years left, and both the buyer and any lender will want to know exactly what happens after that.
- Get a copy of the federal lease: the remaining term, the rent and how it changes, renewal terms, and what the government must approve when the business changes hands
- Ask how the lease is assigned to a new owner and how long that approval takes, and make the sale contingent on it
- Check whether the remaining term satisfies a lender; SBA lenders generally want occupancy that lasts as long as the loan
- At this price, an SBA-financed purchase would also need an independent valuation and, under the Oct. 1, 2026 rules, a quality-of-earnings review for deals of $3 million or more
- Price in the island setting: storm history, insurance costs, and the cost of running the desalination system and water truck
- Ask for the merchandise and food-and-beverage sales separately, since the brand and the T-shirt business are part of what is being sold
Key Takeaways
- Alabama Jack's in Key Largo is listed at $4.9 million for the business, brand, recipes and equipment, not the land.
- The site sits on a federal lease renewed in 2021 for 20 years; the listing says it runs through 2041.
- The Sague family has owned it since 1980; the bar dates to 1947.
- A buyer's first diligence item is the lease: its term, its renewal history and how it transfers.
More from SYR News
- Schooner Wharf Bar's Sale Now Waits on Key West's CRA After an Oct. 14 Board Vote, With a Lease Running to 2036
- Rent Above 10% of Sales? Fix the Lease Before You Sell the Restaurant
- Ann Arbor's Seva, Serving Vegetarian Food Since 1973, Is Listed at $495,000 as Its Owners of Nearly 30 Years Plan to Retire
- Buying a Restaurant for $3 Million or More? Since Oct. 1, Your SBA Lender Must Order a Quality-of-Earnings Report
- New Hope's Oldestone Steakhouse, in an 1870s Church, Is Back on the Market at $4.25 Million After a June Start Near $6 Million
Sources
Miami Herald, "Landmark Florida Keys waterfront bar selling for $4.9M — conch fritter recipe included," by Luisa Yanez (Oct. 16, 2026): https://www.miamiherald.com/news/business/real-estate-news/article317625905.html
Miami Herald, "Alabama Jack's is on the market. What to know about the Florida Keys landmark" (Oct. 20, 2026): https://www.miamiherald.com/news/business/real-estate-news/article317687240.html
CommercialSearch, "World Famous Alabama Jacks Restaurant and Bar," 58000 Card Sound Road listing: https://www.commercialsearch.com/commercial-property/us/fl/key-largo/world-famous-alabama-jacks-restaurant-and-bar/


