Schooner Wharf Bar's Sale Now Waits on Key West's CRA After an Oct. 14 Board Vote, With a Lease Running to 2036
LEASES | FLORIDA
Key West's Bight board unanimously backed assigning the waterfront bar's lease to the owners of the Green Parrot and Half Shell Raw Bar. The final say belongs to the city's redevelopment agency.
By SYR News | Oct. 16, 2026
After four decades under founders Paul and Evalena Worthington, Schooner Wharf Bar at Key West's Historic Seaport is in line for new owners. The Key West Bight Management District Board voted unanimously on Oct. 14 to recommend approving the assignment of the bar's lease to Tidal Shift Ventures LLC, the Keys Citizen reported on Oct. 15.
Tidal Shift was formed by Jeff Sorg and Mike Croce, managing partners of the Green Parrot Bar and Half Shell Raw Bar in Key West. According to the paper, the partners also run three restaurants and bars in St. Augustine, eight in Pennsylvania and a boutique hotel.
Where the deal stands
- Bight Board: unanimous recommendation, Oct. 14
- Final approval: the Caroline Street Corridor and Bahama Village Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA)
- Ownership change: pending until the CRA approves the assignment
- Name: the business will keep operating as Schooner Wharf Bar
- Price and closing date: not disclosed in the meeting documents
- City staff: Senior Property Manager Gary Moreira recommended approval, calling the buyers “extremely well qualified” and noting that the current tenant, Key West Seaport LLC, has met its lease obligations
“A fresh 10-year lease is an asset in a sale, but only the landlord can hand it to a buyer.”
The lease the buyers would take on
- Term: 10 years, Oct. 1, 2026 through Sept. 30, 2036, approved by the CRA in July
- Base rent: $454,396.94 a year, adjusted annually for the Consumer Price Index
- Estimated taxes, insurance and maintenance: about $60,807 a year
- Percentage rent: 6% of annual gross sales above roughly $7.57 million
- Space: about 9,917 square feet indoors and outdoors, with 205 licensed seats, live entertainment, merchandise sales and ticket sales for excursions and tours
- Conditions: roof flashing and sealing repairs identified in a city inspection, plus provisions covering the bar's signature events
Why the lease came first
The order of events is worth noticing. The long lease was approved in July, and the sale followed. For a buyer, a decade of term with known rent is what makes a business worth paying for, and lenders look for a lease that outlasts the loan. A fresh 10-year lease is an asset in a sale, but only the landlord can hand it to a buyer, and here the landlord is a public agency with its own approval calendar.
Sellers who expect to exit within a few years can take a lesson from the sequence: settle the lease term, and the landlord's view of an assignment, before the business goes to market.
Key Takeaways
- Key West's Bight Board unanimously recommended assigning Schooner Wharf Bar's lease to Tidal Shift Ventures on Oct. 14.
- The CRA has the final say, and ownership stays pending until it acts.
- The lease runs Oct. 1, 2026 through Sept. 30, 2036, with CPI-adjusted base rent plus 6% of gross sales above about $7.57 million.
- Price and closing date weren't disclosed.
Sources
Keys Citizen (keysnews.com), “Schooner Wharf Bar set to change ownership after 40 years” (Katrina Nichols, Oct. 15, 2026): https://www.keysnews.com/news/local/schooner-wharf-bar-set-to-change-ownership-after-40-years/article_6656ecb5-f362-4796-a388-06bbb0d781e5.html


