Pizza 51's Founders Sell Both Locations After 22 Years. The Buyer Asked a Fellow Owner for Advice and Gained a Partner
DEALS | KANSAS CITY
Jason and Shannon Pryor handed the Kansas City and Olathe pizzerias to Anthony St. Clair and Spencer Shaw, who bought Ponak's Mexican Kitchen & Bar earlier this year.
By SYR News | Oct. 19, 2026
Jason and Shannon Pryor have sold Pizza 51, the Kansas City pizzeria they opened in a converted gas station in 2004, to Anthony St. Clair and Spencer Shaw, the Kansas City Business Journal reported on Oct. 16. The sale covers both current locations, at 5060 Oak St. in Kansas City and in downtown Olathe.
The deal at a glance
- Sellers: founders Jason and Shannon Pryor, owners for 22 years
- Buyers: Anthony St. Clair, the primary owner, and Spencer Shaw, a partner and investor, according to the Kansas City Star
- Locations: 5060 Oak St., Kansas City, and 200 S. Kansas Ave., Olathe
- Staff: roughly 40 employees, per Olathe Today
- Price: not disclosed
- Plans: keep the core menu and identity, invest in technology and social media, and consider more locations later, Olathe Today reported
- Not included: Milwaukee Delicatessen Company, which the Pryors and partner Jon Gerner will keep and which will drop Pizza 51 branding, per Olathe Today
“A first-time owner with an experienced partner looks very different to a seller than a first-time owner alone.”
How the buyers came together
Shaw, a longtime general manager, bought Ponak's Mexican Kitchen & Bar on Southwest Boulevard earlier this year. St. Clair, who has more than 15 years of business development and management experience, approached him for advice about buying and running a restaurant, and those talks turned into a partnership, according to the Business Journal and Olathe Today. St. Clair is expected to run Pizza 51 day to day while Shaw stays focused on Ponak's.
Why the structure matters
A first-time owner with an experienced partner looks very different to a seller than a first-time owner alone. The pairing gives the Pryors some assurance that the restaurant will be run by someone who has operated before, and gives the new owner a sounding board during the handoff. Jason Pryor told the Star that he and his wife were glad to hand the business to longtime customers and fans.
For sellers with more than one location, the deal also shows the value of a clean package. Separating the deli partnership from the pizzeria sale meant the buyers acquired one brand, two stores and a staff, without inheriting a side business.
Key Takeaways
- Pizza 51's founders sold both locations to Anthony St. Clair and Spencer Shaw after 22 years.
- Shaw bought Ponak's Mexican Kitchen & Bar earlier in 2026; St. Clair will run Pizza 51 day to day.
- About 40 employees and the core menu carry over; the price was not disclosed.
- Pairing a first-time buyer with an experienced operator can reassure sellers.
Sources
Kansas City Business Journal, "Husband and wife hand off Pizza 51 to new owners after two decades," by Leslie Collins (Oct. 16, 2026): https://www.bizjournals.com/kansascity/news/2026/10/16/pizza-51-gets-new-owners-after-22-years.html
Kansas City Star, "Longtime Pizza 51 owners sell pizzeria after two decades," by Katelyn Umholtz (Oct. 17, 2026): https://www.kansascity.com/news/business/openings-closings/article317657642.html
Olathe Today, "Pizza 51 sold: new owners take over downtown Olathe restaurant" (October 2026): https://olathetoday.com/localnews/pizza-51-sold-new-owners-take-over-downtown-olathe-restaurant/


