New Hope's Oldestone Steakhouse, in an 1870s Church, Is Back on the Market at $4.25 Million After a June Start Near $6 Million

November 5, 2026·SYR Editorial·2 min read

FOR SALE | PENNSYLVANIA

The asking price includes the building, the furniture, fixtures and equipment, and the liquor license, and the restaurant is still taking reservations.

By SYR News | Oct. 21, 2026

AI-generated photo

The former New Hope Methodist Episcopal Church at 15 S. Main St. in New Hope, Pa., home to Oldestone Steakhouse, is listed for $4.25 million, Bucks County Today reported on Oct. 19, citing reporting by Jenna Intersimone of MyCentralJersey.com. The property first went on the market in June for nearly $6 million.

The price includes the restaurant's furniture, fixtures and equipment and its liquor license. The listing does not mean the restaurant has closed: Oldestone was still accepting reservations, according to the report.

The property

  • Address: 15 S. Main St., New Hope, Bucks County, Pa.
  • Asking price: $4.25 million (Bright MLS #PABU2133248), more than $1.7 million below the June asking price
  • Size: about 7,000 square feet on about a quarter acre
  • Built: in the 1870s as a Methodist Episcopal church, and a place of worship for more than a century
  • Inside: a roughly 120-seat dining room in the former sanctuary, stained glass, original pews, a downstairs bar, an upstairs loft bar, a private parlor and a third-floor lounge
  • History: Marsha Brown's restaurant opened there in 2003 and closed in 2021; Oldestone followed with steaks and seafood

“Special-use buildings are hard to price.”

What sellers can learn from the reset

Special-use buildings are hard to price. A church conversion with stained glass and a 120-seat sanctuary has few direct comparables, and the pool of buyers for a $4 million-plus restaurant property is small. Cutting more than $1.7 million within about four months shows how quickly a seller may need to adjust when the first price doesn't produce a deal.

  • Keep the restaurant open and busy while it is marketed; a working business supports the price
  • Break out the value of the real estate, the license and the equipment so buyers and lenders can underwrite each piece
  • Expect lenders to appraise an unusual building conservatively
  • Reprice early rather than letting a listing go stale

What buyers should weigh

A property-plus-business package at this price usually means a large equity check and real estate financing alongside any business loan. The included liquor license matters in Pennsylvania, where the number of retail licenses is capped by a county population quota.

Key Takeaways

  • Oldestone Steakhouse's building at 15 S. Main St., New Hope, Pa., is listed for $4.25 million, down from nearly $6 million in June 2026.
  • The price includes furniture, fixtures, equipment and the liquor license.
  • The restaurant remained open and taking reservations.
  • Sellers of special-use properties should price on real comparables and adjust early.

Sources

Bucks County Today, "Former New Hope Church Turned Oldestone Steakhouse Listed for $4.25 Million," by Samuel Knickerbocker (Oct. 19, 2026), citing Jenna Intersimone, MyCentralJersey.com: https://bucksco.today/2026/10/oldestone-steakhouse-for-sale/

Listing: 15 S. Main Street, New Hope, Pa. (Bright MLS #PABU2133248): https://centralbuckshomes.com/properties/listing/Bright/PABU2133248/NEW-HOPE/15-S-MAIN-STREET