A Temp Dishwasher in 2008, an Owner by Oct. 25, 2026: Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria's Longtime Managers Buy the Everett Restaurant

November 5, 2026·SYR Editorial·3 min read

MANAGEMENT BUYOUTS | WASHINGTON

Jonny Elia and Caitlin Hoover ran operations for most of the past decade before buying the downtown Everett pizzeria. The pizza, they say, stays the same.

By SYR News | Oct. 26, 2026

AI-generated photo

Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria in downtown Everett, Wash., has new owners who already know it inside out. Husband and wife Jonny Elia and Caitlin Hoover have bought the business, My Everett News reported Oct. 25. No price was disclosed.

Elia was hired in 2008 as a temporary dishwasher, filling in for a friend who had broken his arm. He stayed, and over the years became general manager, director of operations and a shareholder. Hoover joined in 2017 while finishing graduate school. For most of the past decade the two have been the company's operations directors.

The deal at a glance

  • Business: Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria, a New York-style pizzeria in downtown Everett, nearing its 20th anniversary
  • Buyers: Jonny Elia and Caitlin Hoover, longtime managers; Elia was already a shareholder
  • Reported: Oct. 25, 2026
  • Price and terms: not disclosed
  • Plans: the same pizza, with new ideas to come

“The best buyer for a restaurant may already be on the payroll”

Why management buyouts work

The best buyer for a restaurant may already be on the payroll. Managers who buy know the recipes, the suppliers, the staff and the numbers, so there is less to learn and less chance guests notice a change. Elia's path, from dishwasher to shareholder to owner, also shows a common route: a key manager gets a stake first and buys the rest later.

The new owners told the paper that the menu and the pizza will not change, and they credited the restaurant's management team and staff for its success.

If a manager could be your buyer

  • Start the conversation early; a manager may need years to save or line up financing
  • Consider a small equity stake or profit share as a first step, backed by a written buy-sell agreement
  • Keep clean books, because the manager's lender will review them like any other buyer's
  • Decide whether you will carry a seller note, and for how much
  • Get an independent valuation so the price is fair to both sides
  • Plan your exit, including any consulting period after closing

If you are the manager

  • Learn the whole business, not just your station; Elia and Hoover ran operations across the company
  • Talk with an SBA lender early about the down payment you will need
  • Ask the owner about a path to ownership before a sale is on the table

Key Takeaways

  • Longtime managers Jonny Elia and Caitlin Hoover have bought Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria in downtown Everett, Wash.
  • Elia started as a temporary dishwasher in 2008 and later became a shareholder.
  • No price was disclosed, and the owners say the pizza will stay the same.
  • Owners who groom a manager, including with an early equity stake, can build their own buyer.

Sources

My Everett News, "Brooklyn Brothers Pizzeria Changes Hands" (Oct. 25, 2026): https://myeverettnews.com/2026/10/25/brooklyn-brothers-pizzeria-changes-hands/